THE GOOD , BAD , AND UGLY IN HEDGE : A MANAGER 'S VIEW

Click here to find out more!

* BusinessWeek
* BusinessWeek Exchange

Search all of BusinessWeek.com:
BusinessWeek logo
Unstructured Finance: BusinessWeek's Wall Street News Blog
Current Issue
Free Gift Offer
Subscribe Now

* Home
o Top News
o Special Reports
o Columnists
o Videos
o Newsletters
o The Debate Room
o In Your Face
o Blogs
o Money & Politics
o Green Business
o What's Your Story?
* Investing
o Investing Home
o Markets
o Stocks
o Economy
o Real Estate
o Retirement
o Investing: Europe
o Philanthropy
o Learning Center
o Economics Blog
o Investing Blog
* Companies
o Companies Home
o Sectors & Industries
o Industry News
o Learning Center
o People Overview
o Mobile Application
* Technology
o Tech Home
o CEO Tech Guide
o Computers
o Electronics
o Entertainment
o Internet
o Reviews
o Software
o Investing
o Tech Maven
o Telecom
o Columnists
* Innovation & Design
o Innovation Home
o Architecture
o Auto Design
o Brand Equity
o Game Room
o Innovation Index
o Brand Blog
o Design Blog
o Media Blog
o NEXT Blog
o Columnists
* Managing
o Managing Home
o Your Career
o Your Team
o Your Company
o Your Board
o Books
o Management IQ Blog
o Interactive Case Studies
o Columnists
o Jobs
* Small Biz
o Small Biz Home
o Small Biz Blog
o Getting Started
o Financing
o Marketing
o Leadership
o Communications
o Smart Answers
o Success Stories
o Tech
o Small Biz Magazine
* B-Schools
o B-Schools Home
o Undergrad
o MBA Insider
o MBA Blogs
o Calendar
o Forums
o Getting In Blog
o Rankings & Profiles
o Admissions Q&As
o Journals
o Videos
* Asia
o Asia Home
o China
o India
o Economy
o Innovation
o Investing
o Eye on Asia Blog
* Europe
o Europe Home
o Autos
o Companies
o Economy
o Energy
o Innovation
o Investing
o Europe Insight Blog
* Lifestyle
o Lifestyle Home
o Real Estate
o Autos
o Travel
o Executive Health
o Living Well
o Auto Beat Blog
o Hot Property Blog
o Traveler's Check Blog
* Magazine
o Current Issue
o Past Issues
o Cover Story Podcasts
o Figures of the Week
o Small Biz Magazine
o BW TV
o Subscribe
o FAQs

MyTake March 5, 2009, 12:01AM EST
The Good, Bad, and Ugly in Hedge Funds: A Manager's View
BusinessWeek reader and hedge fund manager Eric Jackson considers the pros and cons of his industry

By Eric Jackson
null

Naples (Fla.)-based BusinessWeek reader Eric Jackson is founder and managing member of Ironfire Capital LLC and the general partner and investment manager of Ironfire Capital US Fund LP and Ironfire Capital International Fund Ltd.
Story Tools

* post a comment
* e-mail this story
* print this story
* order a reprint
* suggest a story
* digg this
* save to del.icio.us

Click here to find out more!

Not too long ago, practically every newly minted MBA wanted to be a hedge fund manager, and investors—including many conservative pension funds and endowments—rushed at the chance to place assets in hedge funds. Yet hedge fund managers were blamed for both artificially inflating the price of oil last summer and, when prices dropped, for contributing to the looming recession.

The mainstream press has now taken to derisively calling them "former masters of the universe," while noting that compensation is still "obscene." As quickly as assets came in during the up market, they have gone out in a declining market. In the last quarter of 2008, $152 billion in hedge fund assets were redeemed, even ones with positive returns in 2008


As a hedge fund manager, I'm neither an apologist nor a cheerleader for my industry. Like any business, the hedge fund world has good and bad practices and managers. All managers need to accept accountability for the trying times we are living through. But it's fanciful to suggest hedge funds are about to disappear. Quite the opposite: The industry will be thriving even five years from now because it will continue to attract the best managers and the most sophisticated investors seeking alpha through innovative strategies. Here are some of the good and bad practices in the industry today:
Barbarians at the Gates


NOTE: the all manager needs to accept accountability for the trying times that we are living through.

Hedge funds have long had "gates" as options available to the fund and/or manager included in their subscription documents. All investors reviewed these prior to making an investment. You haven't heard much about them because hedge funds haven't gone through a sustained down period the way we have in the past six months. As a result, a number of funds have exercised their rights to enforce a gate, reducing how quickly investors can redeem out of the fund. The intent of a gate is to prevent a panicked run on the fund, requiring forced selling, which can be very difficult for funds holding illiquid assets, and which further lowers the value of the remaining investors' assets in the fund.

Gates are a perfectly legitimate operating mechanism and will continue to be part of hedge fund investing. Moreover, as so many funds have decided to use them in the past four months, it is unlikely any one fund will be unfairly penalized by investors when they raise new funds down the road. The managers who will be penalized for putting up a gate are the ones who continue to charge fees after doing so. That's their right under their agreements, but it certainly doesn't engender goodwill, and investors tend to have elephant-like memories.
Overpaid and Underperforming?

Critics have attacked the standard hedge fund compensation model of 2% annual management fee and 20%-of-profits performance fee in light of the industry's poor 2008 performance (-19.2% for the average fund, according to Hennessee Group). Yes, many hedge fund managers made bad calls in 2008, but one-third of hedge funds made money in a year when the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index was down 40%. Only 1 in 1,700 mutual funds made money in the same period, meaning you were 50 times more likely to make money in a hedge fund compared to a mutual fund last year. What is that worth in fees?

Sadly, some hedge fund managers don't help themselves in the court of public opinion. Call it John Thain-itis. Many media profiles of hedge fund managers mention private jets, homes in the Hamptons, and flashy lifestyles, none of which has any predictive value about whether a hedge fund is a good investment. It's always been about the returns over a specific period of time, and the comparable risk-reward of other alternatives to invest their money.
Eyeing High-Water Marks

Hedge funds typically have high-water marks, which require hedge fund managers to make their investors whole before paying themselves performance fees. These high-water marks are going to cast a large shadow in the industry for the next few years.

What high-water marks also do—from an investor's perspective—is level the differences between a hedge fund and a mutual fund or other asset manager. Any investor has to pay a percentage of assets in management fees to a money manager. In the case of hedge funds, an investor pays performance fees only when the manager makes money. Investors also know that hedge funds will invariably attract more talent because the compensation levels are higher than the mutual fund industry or elsewhere.

Some observers feel that high-water marks are not the panacea they seem. In a down year, they argue, you can just shut down your fund to avoid the pain of making back past losses and open up another shop across the street. Although this can and does happen, it's just as common for hedge funds to honor their high-water marks instead of taking the easy way out and shutting down, eliminating the high-water mark, and reopening later.

Bottom line: If managers screw up, they need to face the consequences. It's that kind of Darwinism which makes the industry strong. Investors shouldn't have any qualms about having to pay performance—or more correctly stated, revenue-sharing—fees.
Reconciling Differences

With over 10,000 hedge funds worldwide in 2008, funds naturally vary in size and strategy. Some pursue absolute returns, always seeking to grow capital, no matter the market; others aim to beat the S&P or other benchmark on a relative basis. Absolute and relative performance strategies have different levels of volatility due to the different types of risk they take on.

James Simons of Renaissance Technologies recently announced that his firm would not charge fees to existing investors for its Institutional Futures fund, which was down 12% in 2008, but would still charge fees on its Institutional Equities fund, which was down 16%. The difference between the two funds? The first follows an absolute return strategy, while the second aims to beat the S&P 500 by 4% to 6%, which it did.

There is no question that there's a sea change taking place in the hedge fund industry, which saw its assets decline by $782 billion, to $1.21 trillion, in the past year. That's a Detroit-like drop in demand on a year-over-year basis. Within five years, it's likely the mega-funds will dominate, similar to the private equity world, where you have KKR, Bain, T.H. Lee, and a lot of small fry.
Page 1 2 Next Page
Reader Discussion

Post a comment about this story in Reader Discussion…

Click here to find out more!
BW Extras

* Podcasts
* Mandel on Economics
* Behind the Cover
* CEO Guide to Tech
* more…

* RSS Feeds
* Most Popular
* Top News
* Innovation Trends
* more…

* E-mails
* Asia Insider
* MBA Express
* BW.com Insider
* more…

* Blogs
* Blogspotting
* Hot Property
* Tech Beat
* more…


Business Exchange

Track and share business topics across the Web.

* Featured
* Active
* New

* Career Change 171 new articles 6 users
* Tech Gadgets 292 new articles 4 users
* YouTube 546 new articles 5 users
* Employee Engagement 82 new articles 4 users
* Health Insurance Reform 176 new articles 3 users

* Global Economy 479 new articles 37 users
* Social Networking 1,729 new articles 54 users
* Social Media Marketing 418 new articles 27 users
* US Economy 1,382 new articles 41 users
* Twitter 618 new articles 54 users

* Data Loss Prevention 13 new articles 3 users
* Green Supply Chains 5 new articles 1 user
* Comparative Effectiveness 15 new articles 4 users
* Social Media Privacy 1 new article 5 users
* WebTops 5 new articles 3 users

Click here to find out more!
Most Popular Stories

* Read
* E-mailed
* Discussed

1. Did Obama Cause the Stock Slide?
2. The Music Industry's New Internet Problem
3. February Job Losses: Have We Hit Bottom?
4. A Backlash Against Obama's Budget
5. Jobs: Another 651,000 Lost in February

RSS Feed: Most Read Stories

1. Did Obama Cause the Stock Slide? - BusinessWeek
2. The Music Industry's New Internet Problem - BusinessWeek
3. A Backlash Against Obama's Budget - BusinessWeek
4. Jim Rogers Doesn't Mince Words About the Crisis - BusinessWeek
5. Xanadu: Can This Mall Make It? - BusinessWeek

RSS Feed: Most E-mailed Stories

1. Did Obama Cause the Stock Slide?
2. A Backlash Against Obama's Budget
3. GM's Big Assumptions
4. The Music Industry's New Internet Problem
5. February Job Losses: Have We Hit Bottom?

RSS Feed: Most Discussed Stories
Most Popular Multimedia

* Slide Shows

1. Best Affordable Suburbs 2009
2. The Best Places to Raise Your Kids 2009
3. The World's Happiest Countries
4. America's Best High Schools
5. The Best Cities for Riding Out a Recession

RSS Feed: Most Popular Slide Shows
Ads by Google

* Hedge Fund Research
8,700 Hedge Fund Ratings & Reports from Morningstar. Learn more.
www.Morningstar.com
* Hedge Fund Trading
Single Solution for All Vital Quant Processes. Save Time. Learn More!
www.Clarifi.com/UnmatchedSpeed
* Hedge Funds Analysis
Specialized due diligence investigations for fund managers.
www.spec-oso.com
* Cumulus hedge funds
Information can be requested via steve.brosnan@pceinvestors.com
www.pceinvestors.com

BW Mall - Sponsored Links

* Get up to $500k HSBC Term Life Ins. at HSBCusa.com Apply online today. No medical exam. No agent visit. Get instant coverage if you qualify.
* Subscribe to ETF Newsletter FREE Trial - Invest Like the Pros! Research and analyze exchange-traded funds with our weekly newsletter and online portal.
* Add Your Business Directory Listing Be Visible. Add your targeted business listing to a business directory that gets noticed.
* Stable Investment w/ 15% Annual Return. $25k min. Invest w/ Expert-run Mobile Imaging Centers! Earnings Paid Monthly. $25K min investment.
* Free Real Estate Training 25 Years Of Real Estate Investing Secrets. A $500 Value, Now Free. Sign Up For Instant Access!
* Buy a link now!

Click here to find out more!
Click here to find out more!

Try BusinessWeek Today The ultimate source of business authority, insight and reporting.

Advertising | Special Sections | MarketPlace | Knowledge Centers | Careers | Terms of Use | Disclaimer | Privacy Notice | Ethics Code | Contact Us | Site Map

Copyright 2000-2009 by The McGraw-Hill Companies Inc. All rights reserved.
McGraw-Hill Logo